At the moment we’ve got a lot of people playing ItsYerChoice in our Home School the Dog program. Now, if you are reading my blog for the first time, you might be wondering what ItsYerChoice is. It’s one of my foundation games that teaches dogs HOW to make great choices. And because it’s a game, it’s fun, and we all learn best when we are having fun.
Sometimes people who are introduced to ItsYerChoice wonder what the difference is between educating our dogs they can make good choices, compared to using the traditional “leave it”, or having the dog look at you with “watch me”. It’s such a common question that a couple of years ago I did a short video on Facebook with the answer, but it’s not always easy to find. So, I decided it should be here on my blog to be easily accessible to everyone who has the question, and for everyone to share the answer with family, friends, training buddies and students.
One of the keys of our dogs playing ItsYerChoice is our dogs looking at the treat, and not at us. This is not something I just arbitrarily decided … “let’s not have the dogs look at us”. This was really purposeful. It’s all about layers of training in our program because it is a choice based program. We want the dogs to think for themselves when we are not around or close by. The cookie we use in ItsYerChoice (IYC) ultimately represents every distraction our dogs might have in their life.
And another reason we don’t use “leave it” is because we’d have to be saying “leave it” for our dog’s lifetime … and always micro-managing our dogs as we’ve never taught them they can make great choices.
Remember, the food or toy in IYC represents a distraction. You are now teaching your dog “self-control” rather than “imposed control”. A dog with self-control has learned to have “impulse control” when in stimulating environments. Our dogs learn that good choices have good consequences.
Be the Keeper of the Joy
Hand in hand with IYC is us harnessing the power of permissions so we let our dog know when he can have something he wants! We want to be the keepers of joy, not the stoppers of joy.
The first layer of our dog understanding permissions is the ‘get it’ cue we introduce in ItsYerChoice. The learning in the game carries through to any situation and gives our dogs total clarity. Clear is kind.
Of course, it is super important to understand that you won’t be jumping from your dog playing IYC for the first time to being able to take it straight to a bunny farm. In choice based dog training it is very important that the dog has competence at every layer before adding the next. I covered this in my vlog “Expectations vs Understanding in Dog Training“. We’re not going to play ItsYerChoice with a couple of cookies in your living room and then go to a bunny farm and expect your dog not to make poor choices.
There is also another reason for our dog’s looking at the cookie in ItsYerChoice. Dogs that are trained and live in “Do-Land” have immense value for us. This attention from our dogs is a by-product of effective, inspired training. When you get it right your dog will never want to take his eyes off of you and you will have to create a new response; that of inspired focus forward towards something else! For dog agility, and other sports, we want our dogs to be focused on what they are doing, rather than looking at us.
Today I am grateful for everyone who has joined us in Home School the Dog, you are filling our life with joy and your dog’s life with joy.
This concept is the best one ever. I have GSP I run in agility. She is 100% focused on me and the game. We never fought over attention…I made myself tons of fun and she chooses me over anything else.
Hello – Reading through the comments I have a similar question as Amanda Comegys April 9, 2020 at 10:05 PM
I’m not sure how to use IYC to help my pup from not stealing shoes, remotes etc. The DogsThatTeam referred to a Q&A link
https://www.homeschoolthedog.com/products/home-school-the-dog/categories/2394831/posts/8554148
which does not appear to work any longer.
I have already done the manage and re-direct components but not sure how to use IYC in this way.
Hello David,
Wondering if you got answers to your inquiry?
We absolutely love it’s your choice! It’s part of our everyday play! Thank you❤️❤️
Thank you so much Susan. I want to have fun in agility (small steps) with my new puppy (now 9 months old) but knew I had to start with a great foundation, So I wanted someone that can link the basic training with agility. I found you (fellow Canadian – so proud) to start on the right foot. I don’t want to wrongfully use basic ‘commands’ that may impact my future training in agility with my dog. I love it when you say in your video/podcasts, that there is an issues or impact on the training in agility . You then put it in context. So great!! Keep up the great work!
Hi ,
I love the its your choice game and we play it loads in the home and out and about…… when for me it would be really helpful is to help with my dog scavenging for animal poo on walks,. I got the message that the leave it cue is me managing the situation but I falter at how to apply its your choice to the poo pouncing , how do I work with loo to look for permission to eat something she finds ….It is a skill I think she needs as her passion for eating poo gives her upset stomachs and restricts her freedom and enjoyment on walks or even free access to our garden because she will eat her own poo if not closely supervised
Just tried playing this with my 5mnth old GSP and her response was to bite/hard mouth my hand! repeatedly. I can withstand a bit of a bite/mouth so hoped she would work it out but couldn’t get past the first stage without using a ‘leave it’ I know this isn’t meant to be done but not sure what to do. Switched to another exercise as she seems frustrated. Only first time so keep trying? try at a different time of day? higher value treat? lower value? I was using kibble.
We had this morning an encounter with 2 young ducks very close to our trail. IYC raised dog: looks at ducks and continues walking with me! Love it!
Nevertheless, I have a question: for sure, in agillity you want your dog to be focused on the work but what about musical freestyle where you want this laser focus on you? I do not want my dog to stare at a distraction but to keep her eyes on me. Any thoughts on that? Where am I am missing a piece?
Mini is currently enrolled in HS and has been having a blast playing IYC. I’m also playing this with my senior Nellie.
Thank you so much, Susan and Team!
Hi Susan
I have taught our dog to play it’s your choice, but have not been sure how to layer it up. So when we’re out walking she’s a fiend for eating horse poo or rabbit poo and I want her to make a better choice but haven’t achieved that level. Where is it I need to go in order to access this layering up that you mention in the above video clip. – as I would love to be able to watch this.
Do you have any advice on specific breeds? I have a whippet who wants to be friends with everyone and their dog. I watch out for people/dogs while we are out but occasionally he sees them before I do and if he is out of reach he is off! I call him and make noises he knows but he doesn’t always turn for “home” ie me! he does eventually but not always straight away. I am concerned he will come unstuck running off to greet them but am at a loss on what to do!
“Keeper of Joy” I want that on my resume!
This is very informative and useful post. Thanks for sharing!
I love your blog and I daily read your blog thanks
Hi. Which treat has the higher value? The one on the floor or the one in Susan’s hand that she gives when her dog looks at here after name is said?
Hello … we just rescued a 9-week old puppy, and she went from a totally shy and reserved puppy to a wild and crazy little thing that likes to nip/bite us! What’s the best way to handle?
This is very informative and useful post. Thanks for sharing!
I just shared this blog post on my training business facebook page, which at first seemed like a dumb idea. I mean, why should my students pay ME to teach them, when they can go online and get such great training advice from a person I consider maybe the very best animal animal trainers in the world? But the reason I am sharing this with all my students is because it is such a great clear explanation of such an important part of dog training, and it helps to “back me up” regarding what I do with students in class.
I’ve had people express some doubt around what I want them to be doing. Today actually I had a GORGEOUS great Dane puppy and the breeder I think had told the owner never to feed the Great Dane on the floor, because they wanted the dog to have a habit of looking up, for a nice head up heeling position in competitive obedience. And she had done some some work on getting the puppy to make eye contact, and this puppy was so focused on her — which could seem FANTASTIC when you are thinking that’s what you want — that the puppy couldn’t see anything else.
Anyway, M. was understandably a little bit uncertain about eye contact versus It’sYerChoice & Crate game and also mat targeting (tossed food on the floor), there are so many different opinions out there. Susan Garrett does such a fantastic job of explaining and demonstrating what is possible. Sharing her great programs might redirect some of my business her way? But also, it might help my students become better trainers. It might help members of my training club excel, and it might steer more pet owners into humane training as a lifestyle.
This exercise I think is the one that really helped me understand the intelligence and cooperative nature of dogs, and how important it was to give dogs time think. It helped me understand that value of growing self control incrementally while protecting my own and my dog’s confidence.
Anyway, thank you so much Susan! What a great job you’ve done with your programs! It’s amazing! You’re making the world a better place for dogs and humans! Shine on! And to my students, yeah, Susan’s programs are worth every penny, but my programs are worth every penny too! Do both!
Dear Susan,
I absolutely treasure your training information. It has helped me better understand my 7 mo old Husky/Maltese/Pomeranian puppy. I am one who has been using “leave it”, however, it really no longer works. Especially when he turns what he is NOT supposed to have into a game of keep away.
Do you have any suggestions so that he understands this time it is not a game.
Thank you to you and your team for all you do,
Nancy
Thank you for this video. I have been struggling with getting my dogs to look at the food. They were trained as puppies to look at me…..big mistake but now its fixable
My 13 old week old puppy is great doing what’s your choice with cookie in hand and floor but when we are out walking she dives to eat dirt and goose poop. I’m not sure about the best way to work with her here. Do I call her and reward her for coming even after her mouth is full of icky stuff?
Hi, just a quick question. In the Home school the dog training we give the cue “Search” to get the cookie but in IYC we give the cue “get it”. Is there a difference or it is the same? I am a little bit confused and I think I miss something here. Could you please help me?
Hi Laurence, a guide is that we use “search” to find food when our dog doesn’t necessarily know where that food is, and “get it” mostly when our dog is to retrieve a toy or can get a piece of food he is staring at.
Thank you for your quick reply. Is it okay if I say “break” and throw a cookie on the floor to teach my dog the meaning of the released word? Thank you for your advice on how to do it correctly.
I have a puppy who is is training in a sport where tracking is one of the phases. I want him taking the food on the track right now in his training. How will teaching him using the IYC game afect this? I can see how it will help later on when he has to ignore the rabbit or deer running in the field where we are tracking.
where is the its your choice face book you mentioned please www,? cannot see the link
Hey Janine, you can join us in Home School the dog to learn ItsYerChoice and more. Here’s where to jump in with us:
https://dogsthat.com/home-school/
I love susan garrett dog training you are awesome and the team with every thing you do to help all who are training their dogs
where is the its your choice face book you mentioned please www,? cannot see the link
I love susan garrett dog training you are awesome and the team with every thing you do to help all who are training their dogs
Hi Susan. I just love the training you offer and the philosophy behind it. I have been using the games presented such as IYC and others with my labrador retriever,”Poppy ” since we got her. She is 14 months old now and I really notice the effect of teaching her through play. Thank you so much for your inspiration!
Confusing- would like to join but don’t know where to put promo code in to get this free
Hi Faye, you can join here: https://dogsthat.com/home-school/ On the page, click the orange button that says “Yes, let me start!”
Fighting the vacuum cleaner -fixed. Constant barking at next door’s dog – (almost) fixed. And that’s just after one week of IYC! As to Collar Grab (mastered in one session) – remember a horrible experience with ‘leave it’ type trainer: when dog refused to Wait at door, she grabbed her by the collar, smacked her hind quarters hard and pinned her to the floor. We’re hooked …
Hi, I’ve already trained leave it with my dog, so my dog keeps looking at my face. How do I stop this behaviour?
I only got 2 lessons in homeschool your dog. I got the in on whitemail but it wont work. Help
Hello Jane, login to Home School the Dog and visit the Course Overview page. It shows you when the games will be open in the modules (it works off the date you started). Here’s the Course Overview link:
https://www.homeschoolthedog.com/products/home-school-the-dog/categories/2394886/posts/8070197
Before finding your training philosophy, I worked with what is familiar old school for me ( and several local trainers!), which means I’ve taught our dog to focus on my eyes for commands, releases and rewards. Oh dear. I absolutely see wisdom with the philosophy of “it’s yer choice” and it’s inherent respect for our buddies.
I’d love(!) your advice on transitioning our dog. Oh, such a jump. The dear guy has spent a year learning and now, to continue growing together, I’m going to ask for a whole new style.The linger I wait for a desired shaping action, the more sure he is that his attention on me is the path to fun/food/freedom. Help, please.
Hi Jennifer, try using the most amazing high value treat in the ItsYerChoice Game as Susan covers in the video. Let us know in the Home School the Dog Facebook group how you are going. We’d love to see a short video of you playing. You’ve got this!
I have joined Crate Games and Home School the Dog. My puppy is now 16weeks and like to still shoes, remotes, cat food. How do you suggest teaching her not to take something that is not hers?
Please excuse the spelling …”she likes to steal”
Hi Amanda, Susan covered this today in a Q&A! We’ve got the recording in Home School the Dog for you. Here’s the link for when you are logged in:
https://www.homeschoolthedog.com/products/home-school-the-dog/categories/2394831/posts/8554148